The Indian government, under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has decided to let its ambitious $23 billion Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme lapse, marking a pivotal moment for domestic manufacturing. This decision, which comes just four years after its launch, raises questions about the effectiveness of large-scale incentive programs and India’s ability to compete globally in manufacturing.
A Look at the PLI Scheme: What Was the Goal?
The PLI scheme aimed to:
- Attract global manufacturers to India by providing financial incentives.
- Reduce reliance on China for production.
- Increase manufacturing’s share in India’s GDP to 25% by 2025.
- Promote growth in key sectors such as pharmaceuticals, mobile phones, textiles, and steel.
Key Highlights:
- 750+ companies participated, including Apple supplier Foxconn and Reliance Industries.
- Companies were promised cash incentives upon meeting production targets.
- India set an ambitious production target of $400 billion under the program.
Challenges & Shortcomings
Despite its high ambitions, the PLI scheme faced multiple hurdles:
1. Slow Subsidy Disbursement
- As of October 2024, only $1.73 billion of the allocated funds had been disbursed.
- Firms had produced $151.93 billion worth of goods—only 37% of the target.
- Bureaucratic delays in fund distribution led to dissatisfaction among companies.
2. Limited Success Beyond Key Sectors
- Mobile and pharmaceutical industries flourished under the PLI scheme.
- 94% of the $620 million disbursed between April and October 2024 went to these two sectors.
- Other sectors like steel, textiles, and solar panels failed to achieve the expected growth.
3. Bureaucratic Red Tape
- Excessive regulations hampered progress, with companies struggling to meet compliance requirements.
- The government rejected extension requests for many firms failing to meet production targets.
4. Global Trade Pressures
- U.S. protectionist policies and tariff threats on India added further uncertainty.
- The “China Plus One” strategy failed to drive enough global interest in India’s manufacturing ecosystem.
Sector-Wise Performance Overview
| Sector | Outcome |
|---|---|
| Pharmaceuticals | Success – Exports doubled to $27.85 billion. |
| Mobile Phones | Success – $49 billion production in 2023-24. |
| Steel | Failure – 14 of 58 projects were withdrawn. |
| Textiles | Failure – Failed to match China’s low costs. |
| Solar Panels | Failure – 8 of 12 firms unlikely to meet targets. |
The Road Ahead for India’s Manufacturing Ambitions
- New incentive models: A shift toward reimbursing initial investments rather than post-production incentives.
- Sector-specific support: Focusing on high-growth areas like electronics and pharmaceuticals.
- Streamlining bureaucracy: Reducing red tape to attract foreign investments.
Expert Opinions
Biswajit Dhar, a trade expert at the Delhi-based Council for Social Development, expressed concerns about India’s missed opportunity:
“The incentives program was possibly the last chance we had to revive our manufacturing sector. If this fails, what can succeed?”
FAQs
1. Why is the Indian government discontinuing the PLI scheme?
The government believes that the scheme has run its course and wants to explore alternative methods for promoting manufacturing without extending the current model.
2. What were the biggest successes of the PLI scheme?
The pharmaceutical and mobile phone industries saw massive growth, with exports and production levels significantly increasing.
3. Why did sectors like steel and solar panels struggle under the scheme?
High competition from China, compliance issues, and delays in incentive payouts made it difficult for these sectors to meet targets.
4. What’s next for India’s manufacturing strategy?
The government may shift toward upfront investment reimbursements and sector-specific policies to attract more global manufacturers.
Final Thoughts
While the PLI scheme showed promise in certain industries, its overall impact has been underwhelming. The government’s decision to let the program lapse signals a need for a more refined and focused approach to manufacturing incentives in India. Whether India can capitalize on its manufacturing potential remains to be seen.
Click here to learn more
Pari is a passionate writer known for captivating stories that blend imagination and reality. Inspired by travel, history, and everyday moments, Pari crafts narratives that resonate deeply with readers.